As a developer, you’ve probably faced the challenge of maintaining high code quality while meeting tight deadlines and complex projects. How do you make sure your code is robust, secure, and maintainable without slowing down your workflow? This is where code review tools come into play. Using a good code review tool can make a world of difference. These tools help you catch bugs early, improve code readability, and make sure that best practices are followed. They also facilitate collaboration within your team and make it easier to share feedback and implement changes efficiently.
In this blog, we’ll dive into the ins and outs of code review tools. We’ll explore what they are, their benefits, and the different types available. Plus, we’ll give you a list of the top 10 code review tools you should consider and what to look for when choosing the best one for your projects. Let’s get started!
What Is a Code Review Tool and What Are the Benefits of Using One?
A code review tool is software that assists developers in reviewing and improving their code. It’s like having a mentor by your side who reviews your code for any errors and makes sure that everything is up to standard. But don’t mistake it with just a fancy spell-checker for code. It’s not just for bugs since it can actually improve your code quality, security, and efficiency.
Benefits of Using Code Review Tools
Effective code review tools enhance code quality, collaboration, and security by automating checks, enforcing standards, and facilitating easy feedback, ensuring consistent and reliable codebases. Their documentation and traceability features provide valuable records for future reference and audits.
Improved Code Quality
Code review tools help you produce cleaner, more reliable code because they catch bugs and potential issues early. They highlight errors, suggest best practices, and enforce coding standards so your codebase remains high quality.
Easier Collaboration
Code review tools streamline the feedback process and make it easy for team members to comment on specific lines of code, suggest changes, and approve updates. This collaborative environment helps in sharing knowledge and improving overall team productivity.
Time-Saving through Automation
Automated code review tools can perform initial checks and analysis. So, they free up your time to focus on more complex issues. They can automatically enforce coding standards and detect common errors, reducing the manual effort required for reviews.
Enhanced Security
Security vulnerabilities can slip through the cracks in manual reviews. Code review tools, especially those that have automated features, can detect potential security issues early. This way, they help to protect your applications from attacks.
Consistent Code Quality
By using a standardized review process, code review tools make sure that every piece of code is evaluated consistently. This helps maintain a uniform quality across the entire codebase. So, every chunk of your code has the same quality.
Documentation and Traceability
Some of these tools keep a record of reviews, comments, and changes. This documentation can be invaluable for future reference, audits, or onboarding new team members. So, you can know why certain decisions were made.
By integrating a robust code review tool into your workflow, you can address common issues related to code quality and elevate the security of your code.
Different Types of Code Review Tools
There are lots of code review tools to choose from. But you should note that each category is designed for a specific purpose. Understanding these categories can help you pick the right tool for your projects.
Bundled Tools
Bundled code review tools come integrated with other software development tools, like Integrated Development Environments (IDEs) or Version Control Systems (VCS). These tools offer the convenience of having everything in one place, which makes everything easier. Examples include JetBrains’ ReSharper for Visual Studio or the built-in code review features in GitHub.
Standalone Tools
Standalone code review tools are applications that are solely focused on code review. They often offer more advanced features and customization options compared to bundled tools. Examples include Crucible by Atlassian and Review Board. These tools are ideal if you need a robust, specialized solution for code review.
Based on VCS Support
Some code review tools are designed to work with specific version control systems. For example, GitHub and GitLab have built-in code review tools that integrate seamlessly with their respective VCS platforms. When choosing a tool, it’s important to consider its compatibility with your team’s VCS for a smooth integration.
Based on AI Integration
Code review AI tools are the latest addition to the field of code review tools. These tools use machine learning to provide smarter, more nuanced code reviews. They can suggest improvements, detect complex issues, and learn from past reviews to improve their accuracy over time. Examples include DeepCode and Tabnine. AI integration can bring a new level of sophistication to your code reviews, helping you catch issues that traditional tools might miss.
Based on Workflows
Code review tools can also be categorized based on the workflows they support. Some tools are optimized for pre-commit reviews, where code is reviewed before it is merged into the main branch. Others support post-commit reviews, which allow you to review code after it has been committed. And then there are tools like Phabricator and Gerrit that support both workflows and offer flexibility depending on your team’s preferences.
Based on Automation Features
Automation can enhance the efficiency of code reviews. Automated code review tools use static analysis to automatically check for code quality issues, enforce coding standards, and even detect potential bugs. Examples include SonarQube and CodeClimate. These tools can save you a lot of time and make sure that your code adheres to best practices.
Understanding these different types of code review tools can help you identify which one aligns best with your team’s needs and workflows.
10 Best Code Review Tools in 2024
There are lots of good-quality code review tools out there with great built-in features. But here we’ve listed ten code review software that are most trusted by developers:
1. GitHub Code Review
GitHub’s built-in code review tool is integrated directly into the platform. It’s a great choice for developers who want to collaborate and review code changes within their repositories.
GitHub Code Review Features
- Seamless integration with GitHub repositories.
- In-line comments and discussions.
- Support for pull requests and automated checks.
2. GitLab Code Review
GitLab offers a robust code review system integrated with its CI/CD pipeline. This makes it a comprehensive platform for managing code quality and collaboration.
GitLab Code Review Features
- Merge request reviews.
- Automated testing and continuous integration.
- In-depth code discussions and suggestions.
3. Bitbucket Code Review
Bitbucket’s code review tool is designed to work seamlessly with Atlassian’s ecosystem so it offers strong integration with Jira and Confluence.
Bitbucket Code Review Features
- Pull request management.
- In-line comments and suggestions.
- Integration with Jira for issue tracking.
4. Phabricator Differential
Phabricator’s Differential tool provides a powerful and flexible code review system that is suitable for large and complex projects.
Phabricator Differential Features
- Detailed inline comments.
- Customizable workflows.
- Integration with a variety of version control systems.
5. Crucible
Crucible is developed by Atlassian and works as a dedicated code review tool that supports peer reviews, audits, and defect tracking.
Crucible Features
- Supports various VCS like Git, SVN, and Mercurial.
- Inline and threaded comments.
- Integration with Jira for tracking code review tasks.
6. Review Board
Review Board is an open-source code review tool that supports a wide range of version control systems and is highly customizable.
Review Board Features
- Supports Git, SVN, Mercurial, and Perforce.
- Screenshot reviews and text comments.
- Extension support for additional functionality.
7. Gerrit
Gerrit is a web-based code review tool for Git repositories, designed to facilitate the code review process with powerful access control and workflow capabilities.
Gerrit Features
- Tight integration with Git.
- Customizable workflows.
- Fine-grained access control.
8. Codacy
Codacy provides automated code review and code quality analysis and integrates with a variety of CI/CD pipelines and development tools.
Codacy Features
- Automated code analysis.
- Support for multiple programming languages.
- Integration with GitHub, GitLab, and Bitbucket.
9. SonarQube
SonarQube is a popular tool for continuous code quality inspection because it offers deep static code analysis and integration with various CI/CD tools.
SonarQube Features
- Continuous code quality monitoring.
- Supports numerous programming languages.
- Integration with Jenkins, Azure DevOps, and more.
10. SmartBear Collaborator
Code Collaborator by SmartBear is a comprehensive code review and document review tool that is designed for development and QA teams.
SmartBear Collaborator Features
- Review code, design documents, and test plans.
- Detailed reporting and metrics.
- Integration with Git, SVN, and other VCS tools.
These tools offer a range of features to suit different team needs and workflows, from integrated solutions like GitHub and GitLab to specialized tools like Crucible and Codacy. Choosing the right tool depends on your team’s specific requirements, including the need for automation, AI integration, and compatibility with your existing development environment.
Things to Consider When Choosing a Code Review Tool
Selecting the right code review tool for your development team is so important. A good-quality code review tool can enhance collaboration in your team and make sure the code has standard quality. Here are some key factors to consider when choosing a code review tool for your team or for your personal projects:
Compatibility with Existing Version Control Systems (VCS)
Make sure the code review tool that you choose integrates seamlessly with your current VCS, whether it’s Git, SVN, Mercurial, or others. This compatibility minimizes disruption to your existing workflow and makes adoption smoother.
Support for Automated Code Review and AI Code Review
Automated code review features can significantly speed up the review process by automatically identifying common issues, enforcing coding standards, and highlighting potential bugs. AI-powered code review tools can go a step further by using machine learning algorithms to detect more complex patterns and suggest improvements. So, if you need these two features, make sure to consider them before choosing your preferred code review tool.
Ease of Use and User Interface
Good code quality tools should be intuitive and easy to use, with a user-friendly interface that doesn’t require much training. A clean and organized interface can enhance productivity and make the review process more efficient.
Customizability and Flexibility
Look for tools that allow customization to fit your team’s specific workflows. This includes setting up custom review templates, configuring notifications, and adapting the tool to your team’s coding standards and practices.
Cost and Licensing
Consider the cost of the tool and whether it fits within your budget. Evaluate the licensing options, including any free or open-source alternatives, and weigh them against the features offered.
Community Support and Documentation
A strong community and comprehensive documentation can be invaluable resources. They provide support, tutorials, and forums where you can find answers to common issues and best practices for using the tool effectively.
Collaboration and Communication Features
Effective code review tools should facilitate collaboration among team members. Features like in-line comments, threaded discussions, and integrations with communication platforms (like Slack or Microsoft Teams) can enhance communication and make it easier to resolve issues.
Security and Compliance
Make sure the tool complies with your organization’s security policies and regulatory requirements. This is especially important for industries with strict compliance standards, such as finance or healthcare.
By carefully evaluating these factors, you can choose a code review tool that not only fits your current needs but also supports your team’s growth and evolving workflows.
Conclusion
Choosing the right code review tool can change how you collaborate in your team. It can also help you maintain code quality and streamline your development workflow. Whether you’re looking for automated code review, AI-driven insights, or seamless integration with your existing tools, there are numerous options available to suit your team’s needs. By considering factors such as compatibility, ease of use, customization, and cost, you can find a tool that perfectly aligns with your project requirements.
For Linux developers aiming to maximize their development experience, consider upgrading to a reliable Linux VPS. Our cloud VPS service offers 24/7 support and a 99.95% uptime guarantee which means your applications run smoothly at all times with help available whenever you need it. With robust infrastructure and reliable resources, our VPS is designed to meet the demands of Linux programmers.
FAQ
Is GitHub a code review tool?
Yes, GitHub includes built-in code review features such as pull requests, inline comments, and discussions, making it a powerful tool for code review within its platform.
What is the tool used for collaborative code review?
GitHub, GitLab, Bitbucket, and Phabricator are popular tools used for collaborative code review and offer features like inline comments, merge requests, and threaded discussions.
